10 Common Mistakes in Database Indexing

10 Common Mistakes in Database Indexing

1. Not Having Any Indexes at All

Yes, this happens more often than you’d think. Many developers assume that modern databases are fast enough by default and forget that indexes are what make queries truly efficient.

→ Why It’s a Problem

Without indexes, your database has to scan every row in a table to find the requested data (a full table scan). This works fine for small tables, but once you have millions of rows, queries become painfully slow.

→ How to Fix It

  • Identify slow queries using EXPLAIN (MySQL, PostgreSQL) or EXPLAIN ANALYZE.
  • Add indexes on frequently searched columns, especially those used in WHERE, JOIN, and ORDER BY clauses.

2. Using Too Many Indexes

The opposite of the first mistake—some developers get index-happy and add an index to every column they see.

→ Why It’s a Problem

Each index takes up extra storage and slows down write operations (INSERT, UPDATE, DELETE). The more indexes you have, the more work the database has to do when modifying data.

→ How to Fix It

  • Only add indexes where queries actually benefit from them.
  • Regularly review indexes and remove unused ones using pg_stat_user_indexes (PostgreSQL) or SHOW INDEX (MySQL).

3. Indexing Every Column in a Table

A common myth: “More indexes = faster queries.” This isn’t true because not all indexes are used equally.

→ Why It’s a Problem

  • Indexes aren’t free—each one adds overhead.
  • If a table has 10+ indexes, inserting a row can become extremely slow.

→ How to Fix It

  • Focus on indexing only the necessary columns (not every column in the table).
  • Use composite indexes instead of multiple single-column indexes.

4. Ignoring Composite Indexes

A composite index is an index on multiple columns. Many developers make the mistake of adding single-column indexes instead of a well-thought-out composite index.

→ Why It’s a Problem

Let’s say you frequently run this query:

				
					SELECT * FROM orders WHERE user_id = 123 AND status = 'pending';

				
			

If you create separate indexes on user_id and status, the database might not use both efficiently.

→ How to Fix It

  • Use a composite index instead:
				
					CREATE INDEX idx_orders_user_status ON orders (user_id, status);

				
			
  • Always put the most selective column first in the index.

5. Forgetting to Index Foreign Keys

Foreign keys create relationships between tables, but many developers forget to index them.

→ Why It’s a Problem

Without an index, JOIN operations on foreign key columns are slow, and deleting parent rows can lock the entire table.

→ How to Fix It

  • Always add an index on foreign key columns:
				
					CREATE INDEX idx_orders_user ON orders (user_id);

				
			
  • This helps speed up JOIN queries and cascade operations.

6. Using the Wrong Order in Composite Indexes

Even when developers use composite indexes, they often put columns in the wrong order.

→ Why It’s a Problem

If you index (col1, col2), it helps with:

				
					SELECT * FROM table WHERE col1 = 'x' AND col2 = 'y';

				
			

But it won’t help if your query is just:

				
					SELECT * FROM table WHERE col2 = 'y';

				
			

because indexes work left-to-right.

→ How to Fix It

  • Always put the most commonly filtered column first in the composite index.

7. Not Understanding How Indexes Affect Sorting (ORDER BY)

Indexes help with ORDER BY, but only if they match the query’s sorting order.

→ Why It’s a Problem

If you have an index on (last_name, first_name), this helps:

				
					SELECT * FROM users ORDER BY last_name, first_name;

				
			

But it won’t help much if you change the order:

				
					SELECT * FROM users ORDER BY first_name, last_name;

				
			

→ How to Fix It

  • Align your indexes with your sorting order for better performance.

8. Not Rebuilding or Maintaining Indexes

Indexes need maintenance over time, especially in databases with frequent updates.

→ Why It’s a Problem

  • Fragmentation: Frequent inserts/updates can fragment indexes, making them slower.
  • Bloat: Unused indexes take up space.

→ How to Fix It

  • PostgreSQL: Run VACUUM ANALYZE or REINDEX.
  • MySQL: Use OPTIMIZE TABLE for InnoDB.
  • SQL Server: Run ALTER INDEX … REBUILD.

9. Not Testing Index Performance

Many developers add indexes blindly without testing their impact.

→ Why It’s a Problem

Some indexes actually slow down performance instead of improving it.

→ How to Fix It

  • Use EXPLAIN (MySQL, PostgreSQL) to see if an index is being used.
  • Remove unused or inefficient indexes.

10. Assuming Indexes Solve Everything

Indexes speed up reads, but they don’t fix all performance issues.

→ Why It’s a Problem

  • Indexes slow down writes (every insert/update modifies indexes).
  • Bad query design still causes problems, even with indexes.

→ How to Fix It

  • Optimize queries before adding indexes.
  • Use caching (Redis, Memcached) for frequently accessed data.

Conclusion

Indexes are powerful tools, but only when used correctly. If you find your database slowing down, check for these mistakes:

→ Are you missing indexes on frequently queried columns?
→ Are you using too many or unnecessary indexes?
→ Are you optimizing composite indexes correctly?
→ Are you maintaining and testing your indexes?

Leave a Reply